Harsh Toke: Crisis on Infinite Earths
August 29, 2005

If you read comics, you know what Crisis is, and no doubt have your own opinion about it. If you don't, here's a quick rundown: Crisis is a mega-series run by DC Comics in 1985 for the dual purpose of celebrating their history as a comics publisher and cleaning up the confusing (to some; just as many people liked it, but that's neither here nor their) parallel-worlds setup of the DC Universe. It was a big deal, and is one of the things that you pretty much have to read if you're going to even attempt to follow the history of Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, or anyone else in the DC stable.

Unfortunately, Crisis sort of sucks.

The sins of Crisis are legion: It's too long. The caption narration is so purple that it moves into the ultraviolet. The dialogue is stilted even by 80s comic book standards. Despite George Perez's rightfully-earned reputation as an ace artist, all of the new characters created specifically for Crisis look ridiculous (The Monitor is an old man with muttonchops AND CORNROWS! Pariah suffers from a terrible purple haircut, a lot of eye makeup, and a constant crybaby face. Lyla looks OK as Lyla, but her Harbinger getup is the worst sort of 80s cyborg cheesecake). Many of the old characters just show up for a panel or two, reinforcing the notion that Wolfman and Perez had a checklist of all possible DC characters who had to be represented, whether or not they actually contributed to the story. The big villain, the Anti-Monitor (whose character design is also pretty silly), is an archetypal unmotivated villain. he's bad just because the plot requires him. Worse, he's always exactly as powerful as the plot requires-he spends most of the book annihilating universes, but when it's time to wrap things up, all it takes is a punch from a stupendously pissed-off Superman to take him out.

Crisis isn't all bad-the deaths of the Flash and Supergirl are great moments in comics, and the subplot wherein Lex Luthor and Brainiac marshal all supervillains into an army is pretty fun. But for the most part, Crisis is to comics fandom as The Faerie Queene is to English lit: you've got to read it, but damn, it's a drag.

For a deeper explanation of Crisis, check out:

Comics 101

and

The Howling Curmudgeons

--Keith Pille

American Nerd Mag Home

all content © 2005 the authors and American Nerd Magazine. come on, pal. play nice.